Etf Vs Index Fund-ETF Vs Index Fund-What is the Difference Between ETF and Index Fund

ETF Vs Index Fund

When an investor purchases a passive fund, the management simply constructs a portfolio to mimic an index, such as the NIFTY 50 or the Sensex, and allocates the portfolio’s holdings to mirror that of the index. Investors in passive funds do not have any active role in the management of the fund. Two options now exist for passive investment strategies. Investing in a mutual fund, and more particularly, an index fund, is one option available to buyers. As an alternative, you might purchase shares in an exchange-traded fund. The etf vs index fund will be covered in-depth in this article, along with some examples for your convenience.

Let me offer you a straightforward explanation of this topic if you find yourself similarly befuddled. Active investment and passive investing are the two main options available to investors. If you opt to invest in a fund that is actively managed, the money will be handled by a professional who will use the investor’s specific set of skills and knowledge to construct and monitor a portfolio. You put your trust in the fund management to select the highest-yielding stocks and to perform tactical trades like buying and selling on your behalf.

ETF Vs Index Fund

Index funds are a type of mutual fund that invests in securities supposed to be representative of a fictitious sector of the market in order to mirror the performance and composition of a specific financial market index. You can’t invest directly in an index, but you could invest in a fund that does. This is a form of “passive trading,” in which you select a group of stocks to follow without actively attempting to affect their performance. In the world of finance, doing nothing is a common strategy.

These funds offer cheaper expenses and fees than actively managed funds since they track a common index. One such average is the Nasdaq 100, while another is the S&P 500. Shares of a mutual fund designed to mimic an index can usually be purchased by anyone interested in investing in index funds. This article will go into etf vs index fund in detail and provide some examples for your convenience.

How to Trade

Index funds are a specific category of mutual funds. Conversely, an ETF operates more as a stock would. This is due to the fact that ETFs, unlike stocks, can be traded on exchanges around the clock. As a result, the value of an ETF fluctuates as the market trades.

However, investors can only buy or sell index funds once a day, after the market has closed. Those who are looking to make a long-term investment should not fear. Exchange-traded funds with features like intraday trading, stop losses, order limitations, and so on can be useful if you attempt to time the market.


Mutual fund managers simply add your investment to the fund’s total assets under management (AUM) and use the money to purchase stocks with similar characteristics as the benchmark. There is no genuine worry regarding liquidity when investing in index funds because the converse is true when you wish to withdraw your money.

On the other hand, ETF investors should be concerned about a potential liquidity crisis. Because purchasing an ETF is similar to purchasing any other equity share, index fund purchases are substantially different. Imagine you have 100 units of your ETF available for sale, but no one is interested in buying them. You would be in a bind if you tried to sell your ETF units here due to trading issues; you wouldn’t be able to get the price you desired for them.

Despite this, there is no doubt that major ETFs in India are experiencing improved liquidity. However, low trading volumes are a challenge for exchange traded funds, especially smart beta and industry etf vs index fund.

Sip Availability

Common people often choose “systematic investment plans,” or “SIPs,” to invest their savings. Monthly cash flows have consistently exceeded 8,000 crore rupees over the past few months. The SIP option is not typically available for ETFs, in contrast to index funds.

This is why the inability to invest in ETFs via the SIP method is such a drawback. A systematic investment plan (SIP) is a disciplined and trustworthy approach to investing in the stock market. Therefore, index funds may be the ideal option if you are more comfortable investing in stocks through SIPs.

Charges and Costs

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and index funds are similar in many ways, but the primary distinction is in how they handle. Like stocks, ETFs purchase and sell through a broker on a centralized market. Index funds can purchase directly from the fund’s management.

Since ETFs trade on an exchange, the services of a broker will cost you a percentage of any profit you make. It doesn’t matter if you purchase, sell, or hold an ETF, this is always the case. (However, you may find a dealer who offers commission-free trades.)

Errors in buying and selling ETFs and index funds are exacerbated by dividend payments. Dividends from index mutual funds can automatically reinvest (at no additional expense) into new fund shares. This is etf vs index fund.

Error in Tracking

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are able to more closely monitor the performance of an underlying index because they have a lower tracking error than index funds. This is because index funds retain a small amount of cash on hand at all times to cover potential refund claims. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) used by asset management firms are exempt from this kind of regulation.

Because of the low initial investments, setting up an index fund is a time-consuming process. This is why people are putting their money into index funds. Consider the NIFTY 50 Index Fund as an illustration. There are fifty individual equities included in the Index, and their relative positions vary. This means that the managers of an index fund have to allocate their money each day in the same way that the index does.

To buy all 50 equities that make up the NIFTY 50 index in exactly the same proportions would cost the fund manager Rs. 15 lahks. The fund did, however, receive Rs. 10 lakh on a specific day. This means that the fund’s managers will have to wait until the NIFTY 50’s value rises by Rs. 50,000 before they can buy all fifty companies in the index at the same weighting as the index.

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) do not have this issue. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are mutual funds in which investors can purchase shares through the open market. Your fund manager need not hold any of your money or wait until it accumulates enough cash to buy stocks in a proportional fashion to the index. This is good etf vs index fund.

Differences in Tax

401(k)s and IRAs, which offer valuable tax benefits, are excellent vehicles for long-term investors investing for retirement. As an added bonus, you may completely overlook the nuanced intricacies of how investing in various sorts of funds affects your taxes, which is both sensible and convenient (as we all know that paying less in taxes means having more money in our pockets). That’s why I consider it a smart move.

Expense Ratio

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and index funds typically have lower expense ratios compared to actively managed mutual funds. An investor can learn how much it costs a financial institution to manage their money by looking at the expense ratio. In most circumstances, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) will save you money compared to index funds.

In comparison to the HDFC NIFTY 50 Index Plan, the HDFC NIFTY 50 ETF has a lower fee ratio (0.05%). There is an index fund that corresponds to the HDFC NIFTY 50 ETF named the HDFC NIFTY 50 Index Plan. That’s a three-hundred-percent premium over equivalent exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or an increase of 0.15 percent.

However, ETF investors should be aware of two additional expenses. The first of these costs is the commission your broker takes out of each trade. The broker’s fee is often a set rate per transaction or a percentage of the total amount exchanged. Common components of this fee or commission include trade, GST, STT, stamp duty, exchange fees, SEBI turnover tax, and so on.

When buying and selling ETF shares, the bid-ask spread represents the second transaction cost. This expense is equivalent to a nominal transaction fee and incorporates into the ETF’s asking price. These are the two expenses that must factor into the overall cost of ETFs before a price/performance comparison can make with index funds.

Fund Management Style

Conversely, investors can choose between passive and active management of exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Passively managed instruments include index funds. Currently, approximately 20% of all traded ETFs in the United States are actively managed. The ETF’s active management involves a team of investors actively deciding which stocks to buy, which to sell, and so on as part of the portfolio construction process.

The strategies employed by some of these dynamic ETFs can be quite ingenious. To create an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that mimics the strategies of famous investors like Warren Buffett or Rakesh Jhunjhunwala, it is common practice to simply replicate their portfolios. The ARK Innovation ETF that Cathie Wood helped create is yet another innovative form of exchange-traded fund.

The majority of the exchange-traded fund’s holdings are in what the fund managers call “disruptive innovation,” which includes enterprises involved in areas like DNA analysis, industrial disruption, health technology, and the next generation of the Internet. Although many ETFs operate similarly to index funds, not all ETFs are passive investments.

Minimum Investments

The low entry point of one share for many exchange-traded funds (ETFs) makes them an attractive option for those with only a modest sum to invest. Recently implemented adjustments by a select group of fund managers have resulted in lower entry barriers to some of their most well-known index funds. Below is a table summarizing the entry requirements for S&P 500 mutual funds offered by three of the world’s most prestigious asset managers.


Should i have both ETFs and Index Funds?

Index funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are excellent tools to construct a portfolio with exposure to many different asset classes. By purchasing an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that tracks the S&P 500, you have exposure to hundreds of the most successful corporations in the United States. You may find exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that mirror the S&P 500 here.

Are ETFs or Index Funds Safer?

Because they both depend on the fund’s holdings, index funds and exchange-traded funds cannot compare in terms of safety. Stocks are riskier than bonds, but they often offer a higher rate of return for investors.

Why should i Invest in an Index Fund Instead of an ETF?

Choices have broadened. Mutual funds’ primary advantage over ETFs is their access to a broader selection of investments. The sheer number of available mutual funds is staggering. They can purchase to cater to investors of varying risk preferences, investment horizons, and philosophical orientations.

Final Words

The minimal risk, low maintenance, and low cost of index funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) make them attractive investment options. However, the adage that “one size fits all” does not apply here. Consider the asset class that the fund tracks and the level of diversification that you desire before committing to an ETF or index fund.

The next step is to evaluate the fees associated with buying and selling investments, as well as the expense ratios of each fund. Continue reading to become an expert in ETF vs index fund and learn everything you can about it. Advancing your education on features of mutual funds can be achieved by reading more.

Scroll to Top